Seneca Moral essays
Seneca: When sponges were not forthcoming, he ordered…
When sponges were not forthcoming, he ordered the wretched men’s clothes to be torn up, and the rags stuffed into their mouths. What savagery was this? Let a man draw his last breath: give room for his soul to escape through: let it not be forced to leave the body through a wound.
The passage follows a public-domain translation of Seneca’s moral essays. The reading beside it is ours.
The point of describing extreme cruelty is not to make us feel superior to monsters from the past. It is to show what happens when anger and power lose all regard for another person's humanity. Once someone becomes merely an obstacle, an enemy, or a problem to be disposed of, almost any treatment can seem permissible. We see smaller versions of this whenever people delight in someone else's public humiliation or demand consequences without asking whether they are proportionate. Justice must sometimes be firm. But firmness without humanity becomes savagery. Before you punish, fire, expose, or condemn someone, remember that they remain a person, not a prop in your outrage. Ask what is necessary, what is fair, and what restores order without adding needless pain. The ability to stop before cruelty begins is one of civilization's daily disciplines.
Related passages
- Seneca He best knows the time at which he ought to show favour to each man: I will use my utmost efforts to prevent his…
- Seneca Be assured that the same thing would be the case if no one’s offence is pardoned: it will quickly be discovered how…
- Seneca Clemency, then, makes princes safer as well as more respected, and is a glory to empires besides being their most…